When Dean asks him where he got the knife, Alastair said he got it from a friend who doesn't ride a pale horse but has 3 amigos. That makes me think he got it from one of the 4 Horsemen...Just a theory but that seems to make sense and it makes me wonder which one.

I heard of the expression death rides a pale horse, so maybe he's talking about death.

I don't know but the 3 amigos part doesn't make sense then. I just thought maybe it was his way of saying he got it from one of the 4 horsemen and the show hinting at it for this season.

Death is one of the four horsemen. I think that Alistair was alluding to death, but say they got it wrong when they said he rode a pale horse.

Death is one of the 4 Horsemen? I thought it was Disease, Famine, War, and something else....Unless Charmed got it wrong but that wouldn't surprise me.

This is from Wikipedia

Source

Oh thanks! I see that on the chart it even says Death has a scythe. Makes sense that only his weapon could kill a Reaper. Haha.

I still love how they hinted at one of the 4 Horsemen though. i didn't notice it the first time around.

Death's horse is actually very vibrant. He... well... he's a flaming sodomite, really. His horse is yellow, green, red, and blue and they all mix together and switch on him at any given time. And he has a habit of looking at it and saying, "Now THAT'S a horse of a different color!"

Very good ep: Dean and Sam seem to have lots of un to be ghosts.
But I'm sorry that Pamela dies, I liked her, she was one of the few women of the show that I like