So I had this idea of writers posting stories on here to get honest feedback on, with the understanding that people are not just going to outright bash you, but tell you what they like or don't like about your piece, why this is, and how you can improve the not-asgood stuff.

As a writer myself, one of the most frustrating things is constantly just being told it's good, but thats it. I dont know where to go with a story to make it better because I cant really figure out exactly what a story of mine lacks, I just know that something is wrong. And I dont have any friends who are writers either, so getting helpful feedback is pretty much impossible.

So I decided to bring this thread to life for all those out there who are in the same place. Post anything here-fanfiction or not, Supernaturally themed or not.

(mods, I appologize if this thread is in the wrong place, but please dont delete it!)

also, If you want to eventually chose writing as a career, this thread may be helpful to you.

Dream you rock for starting this thread.

Any way I only have one story on here. And it's almost done but it could always stand to be improved. And I would love some honest critic of the story and any suggestions for making it better. I'm known to re-write, re-write, re-write from time to time. Any way here is the link http://z14.invisionfree.com/Supernatural/i...showtopic=41431

Cool idea for a thread. This is fine how it is, but I just wanted to let you know we do have a Writing Cafe for SN fic down in the fanfic section. ;)

thanks. I had no idea. this is a thread for writing in general, so i hope its ok...

This is a cool idea. I'm going to move this to the fan fiction section.

Tracking this. As a perfectionist, I'm always on the lookout for feedback. :D

Apologies for the double post, but I have posted the first Chapter of a story that I'd been bouncing around in my head. My aim's writing this like it could be an episode of the show in the current season. Hopefully as it continues, it'll feel like that.

So if anyone's up for telling me what they like, don't like and why, I'd be all ears to hear it.

http://z14.invisionfree.com/Supernatural/i...showtopic=42509