I disliked Season 2 'cause of the sci-fi aspect to it. I'm NOT a fan of sci-fi. I like the action, drama, comedy, and horror much better!

You forgot the option of none of them. ;)

Which is what I would have picked.

April

I actually love all three.

I have to agree with April. I believe that season two was better than season one, but I can't say which is better between one and three. Part of that has to do with the strike and having such a long break between episodes. Also, each season is so differant it's almost impossible to really campare them. Right now I find it difficult to watch season one because it was so hopefull and right now he are at such a seemingly hopeless place in the show right now. For me my favorite episode/season change from week to week depending on what is currently happening in the show.

This is such a negative poll - I loved all three seasons. I'm with April - I'd pick None.

None of the above. But yeah, season one now makes me sad. Oh boys :cry

I liked all three seasons. All three had their pluses and minuses. But personally I thought they had more pluses. I'm still bitter that Season 3 was cut short!

I honestly loved all of the seasons. They all had their ups and downs, but in the end all turned out to be great. At this point, I can't really say which season is my favourite or least favourite because... I like them all. I can't decide.

I Find That With The Shows That I Like... The First Few Seasons Are The Best... Then I'm Just Hooked After That And Want To See How It Ends (Which A Lot Of My Shows Never End :( )

S3 saw an episode from Mysery Spot on and had some really good episodes towards the end unfortantly it had more bad then good. I loved S1 and floved S2 but I really thought for the most part S3 sucked. I hated the brighter goorier, more surface SN it lacked the charm and heart of the first 3 seasons and I hated how they where screwing with the boys bound and it was cruder and all around badly writtern except the second half and I hated Rublea and found them intresive, annoying and pointless and felt it was trying to do much too fast and forgetting the MOTW and the Winchester drama which was the heart of the show. S3 was the worst and too me from a SN lover to almost stopping the show completly.

I think that you can't keep watching a show if you don't like one of the seasons, unless this one is the last one, I mean if you picked the 1st. or 2nd. what did you watch the 3rd??, were you giving it a second chance??, my point is that it's possible you don't like some episodes from one season, but you can't hate it or believe that's the worst ever, no if you're still being part of the regular audience, that's why I can't vote because I really like all of the seasons, I think they were good in different ways.

I've liked them all - lliked the way the guys' relationship changed and developed, loved the stories and the arcs. Can't say there's one season I don't adore!

I think all seasons had there own spin to it. Of course none of the seasons were the same. On episodes though, there were some I didn't like in S1,2 and 3, wonder if there will be any in season 4? Can't it already?

First of all, I must have missed a bunch of Season 2 episodes because I don't remember anything Sci-Fi about the ones I saw.

But as far as worst Season, even though it ended with a bang and gave us some classics . . Season 3.

I hate season 3 with a freakin' passion it was only watchable cause of Jensen. :wub: I thought last four episodes of season 3 were the best the rest were focused on other characters to much for my liking. :uzi Ruby comes to mind. :rolleyes:

i love all seasons each is little different,season one i really like it no i love it man cause its more dark than bright like s3 and it didn't have a''love scene'' like in s2 which is why heart was bad in my opinoin,but all seasons are great and s4 will be great too as long as jared & jensen are both on the show.

well i hated season 3.. i wanted them to take on the trickster.. man i hated that low level demon! if they can get the christmas demons, how come they couldnt get this guy!???

and i really do hope he's out there poking on one of the Executives in our office who is so bitchy, and bossy and is powertripping

i lost my bannerrrr!! help mehhhhhhhhhhhhh :(

If I recall (Tall Tales) the trickster is very far from a low-level demon. He has the ability to conjure food or anything for that matter, change his appearance at will and he put Sam into a time loop (Mystery Spot). The trickser is a demi-god if I recall correctly, some sort of deity but definitely more powerful than a low-level or any other demon we've met. They did kill the Christmas pagan gods, I suppose the trickster is more powerful than them and he also outsmarted the brothers in Tall Tales.

Like Shannon said, each season had something to it, each is different from the other. The only thing that didn't change was the fact that I enjoy watching the show and eagerly await the next instalment.

i choose the none of the above option that i'm pretending is there.

I love all 3 Seasons each in different ways.

Yup!.. no choice for me either... every season is special in my heart, S-1 get to know the boys ... S-2 lots of bonding moments that made me head over heels towards the boys and S-3, Dean's 1 year to live, his struggle to keep Sam from seeing his vulnerability...and so forth and so on... :wub: :wub:

from Wicca......I didn't like season 3......because we were only given 16 episodes due to the writer's strike. I didn't like the new girls being referred to as regulars....and Jim Beaver only as a guest star. Jim Beaver is a great actor and being in season's 2 and 3 he is more of a regular than the girls. I didn't like Kripke's move to send Dean to hell....because being a hero figure and since Kripke calls the boys the angel figures of Supernatural....then Dean didn't deserve being sent to Hell's limbo. <_<

I love every episode of every season of Supernatural.

I'd have to say S3 too.

I'll chalk most of it up to the writers strike since I know they couldn't change/rewrite a lot of the stuff while they were filming it. It had some good/great epis but it's the season I had the most "issues" with ;)

Each season was different and had some magnificent episodes and some episodes that were just okay. I love it how the brothers' characters and their genuine relationship have kept developing. I also love it how Jared and Jensen have improved their brilliant acting. I won't choose one favourite season 'cause I simply love them all!

Hopefully the next season will be great 'cause I'm planning on being a devoted fan of this show 'til its end and even after that. :D

I pick none! I love all three seasons! :D

I didn't pick anything too. I'm loving the three seasons, though I can't decide which one I love the best :lol:

I officially hate both the Writers' Guild of America AND tv networks for ruining season 3. It was on the fast track to being the best, but the second half of the season just....I don't know, fell flat. I think that after the strike, the writers might have been a little too concerned with popping out episodes, instead of focusing on the quality of the story. :(

Really? I thought it was on its way to jumping the shark until they got back on track with the last 8 episodes

All seasons had different aspects of horror/action/etc.

I liked Season 1 and 3,Season 2 was alright. But I didn't really hate any of them...

Ditto to your first and second paragraph Guywiththegun.

Although Season 3 was my least favourite, I almost forgive it becuase of the awesome last 5 or 6 eppies. Particularly *sob* the finale.

And because of that I am supremely optimistic about Season 4.

CAN.NOT.WAIT.!

:D

Liked all 3 Seasons. Just wish we had more episodes in Season 3.

I pick none too.

Loved all the three,maybe S1 is special because shows the beginning of the relationship between the boys, they just start to know each other and that's great. But right now i can't watch the old episodes because i know what happens in S3 and that's unbearable.

Sci FI?? Which show are you talking about?

:lol:

I cant cast a vote in on this since Ive enjoyed all seasons.

I voted for season 1 because I'm absolutely addicted to season 2, I love season 3 and I like season 1. I don't really dislike or hate any season of SPN so far, I can only judge by the numbers of favorite episodes in each season. It's definetely easier to say what's your favorite season than to have a least favorite.

honestly i would have to say season 3...not that i hated it but i just didn't love it or anything.

I love all three seasons :wub:

But, if I could only have one season on DVD, I'd pick season 1.

Each episode of each season has memorable scenes that I love and can never forget.

If, as Eric mentioned, he patterns season 4 after season 1, I will be very happy. I like it when Supernatural takes itself very seriously so I don't care for the comedy episodes except the mild comedy of Hellhouse in season 1.

I'll go against the grain here. Season three's been my favorite, save the two clunkers, "Red Sky at Morning," and "Dream a Little Dream of Me." Season one is my least favorite if I must make a choice. Jared was still learning his craft during season one. Overall, it had the weakest episodes. I enjoyed season one, but I don't wish for it to come back.

Same here, I've loved S3 best apart from those very same episodes. :) But my least favourite season is S2.

I hear you. B) I think I'm the only person who didn't enjoy "Dream a Little Dream of Me" so much. It felt very incomplete.